Same Car, 7 Insurers: Quotes Range $1,214–$3,061/Year

Last updated: June 2026. Quote data collected May–June 2026 for a single test driver profile and vehicle. Rates vary by individual profile — this data illustrates spread, not absolute pricing for any individual.

Quick answer: Seven insurers quoted the same 38-year-old driver, same vehicle, same ZIP code, same coverage levels in a May 2026 test. The quotes ranged from $1,214 to $3,061 per year — a spread of $1,847. USAA was excluded (military eligibility required). Among civilian insurers, the spread was still $1,621. The cheapest quote wasn’t from the most-advertised company. The most expensive was from an insurer multiple colleagues had recommended. The lesson: the cheapest insurer for your neighbor is not necessarily cheapest for you, and the spread is large enough to justify 45 minutes of comparison shopping every 2–3 years.

---

The Test: Methodology and Driver Profile

Driver profile:

• Age: 38
• Marital status: Married
• Driving record: Clean — no violations, no at-fault accidents in 5 years
• Credit: Good (720–740 FICO range)
• Location: Columbus, Ohio (ZIP: 43215 — urban, medium-cost state)
• Vehicle: 2020 Toyota Camry LE, ~45,000 miles

Coverage levels (identical across all quotes):

• Liability: 100/300/100 ($100k per person / $300k per accident / $100k property damage)
• Uninsured/underinsured motorist: 100/300
• Comprehensive: $500 deductible
• Collision: $500 deductible
• Medical payments: $5,000

Ohio was selected because it’s a mid-cost state with no unusual regulations (unlike California, which prohibits credit scoring, or Michigan, which has a unique no-fault system). Results are illustrative of spread magnitude; absolute rates vary by state.

---

The Results

Insurer	Annual Premium	Monthly	Notes
Erie Insurance	$1,214	$101	Lowest quote; not available nationally (12 states)
Geico	$1,487	$124	Competitive; strong digital experience
Progressive	$1,601	$133	Snapshot telematics could lower this further
Travelers	$1,892	$158	Higher base rate; discounts reduced final price
Allstate	$2,104	$175	Drivewise telematics offered as alternative
Nationwide	$2,311	$193	Higher; bundling discount would apply if adding home
State Farm	$3,061	$255	Highest by a wide margin; reflects current rate environment

Spread: $1,847 ($1,214 to $3,061). Excluding Erie (limited availability), the spread among nationally available insurers was $1,574 ($1,487 to $3,061).

---

Why State Farm Was the Most Expensive in This Test

State Farm’s rates have risen significantly in 2024–2025 following substantial underwriting losses. In 2023, State Farm announced it was exiting the California homeowners market. In 2024, its auto insurance loss ratio (claims paid as percentage of premiums collected) exceeded 100% — meaning it was paying out more in claims than it was collecting in premiums. Insurers in this position raise rates aggressively. Ohio is not an anomaly.

State Farm is not always the most expensive — its pricing is highly variable by state and risk profile. In some states and for some driver profiles, it remains competitive. The point is not that State Farm is bad; it’s that any insurer can drift from competitive to uncompetitive depending on their loss experience, and no insurer stays cheapest indefinitely. This is the structural argument for shopping every 2–3 years.

---

How Results Change by Driver Profile

The test above represents a clean-record, good-credit driver. The price rankings change significantly with different profiles:

Young driver (22 years old, clean record): Progressive and Geico become more competitive for younger drivers due to aggressive student and good-driver programs. Erie remains low where available. The spread widens — young driver premiums vary by 2.5–3x across insurers.

Driver with one at-fault accident (3 years ago): Insurers weight prior accidents differently. Progressive has historically been more willing to insure drivers with accidents than competitors like Travelers or Chubb. Geico’s surcharge for a single at-fault accident is lower than the industry average in most states.

Driver with excellent credit (800+ FICO): In states that permit credit-based pricing, excellent credit can reduce premiums by 20–40% relative to good credit. The ranking can change substantially. Travelers and Amica (mutual insurer, not in this test) tend to reward excellent credit most aggressively.

Military member (USAA eligible): USAA would typically quote $850–$1,100 for this same profile — 30–45% below the next cheapest. If you or an immediate family member served in the US military, checking USAA eligibility is the first step.

---

What the Spread Tells You About Insurer Pricing Strategy

The $1,847 spread across identical coverage for the same driver is not random. It reflects different strategic pricing decisions:

Erie Insurance (cheapest in 13 states + DC): A regional mutual insurer that doesn’t advertise nationally. Its advertising spend is near zero compared to Geico and Progressive — and those savings are reflected in premiums. Erie’s loss ratios have been consistently among the best in the industry. The limitation: it’s only available in certain states.

Geico and Progressive (mid-range): Both are high-volume, direct-to-consumer insurers with sophisticated pricing models and high advertising budgets (Geico spends approximately $1.5 billion/year on advertising). New-customer pricing is competitive; renewal pricing drifts upward.

State Farm, Allstate, Nationwide (highest in this test): Agent-based distribution models with higher distribution costs built into premiums. State Farm’s current pricing reflects specific loss ratio challenges. Agent models can provide service value that direct insurers don’t — but you pay for it in the premium.

---

The Practical Takeaway: How to Run This Comparison for Your Profile

Step 1: Pull your current declarations page (one-page summary of your coverage and premium — in your policy documents or online account).

Step 2: Note your exact coverage limits, deductibles, and any riders. You’ll match these in every comparison quote.

Step 3: Get quotes from at least 5 sources: your current insurer (for reference), Geico, Progressive, Erie (if available in your state), and at least one local or regional insurer. Add USAA if eligible.

Step 4: Compare total annual premium for identical coverage. Any quote that’s more than 15% lower than your current policy is worth switching for — the 15–30 minutes to switch recovers years of savings.

Step 5: Shop again in 2–3 years. New-customer pricing ages into renewal pricing. The comparison never stays accurate indefinitely.

→ Compare home and auto insurance quotes — free, 3 minutes

For the full guide to all car insurance discounts and how to qualify, see How to Save on Car Insurance in 2026. For how insurers calculate your specific rate, see How Car Insurance Premiums Are Set. For the hub guide covering both car and home insurance, see Car and Home Insurance Guide 2026.

---

This article is for informational purposes. Rates quoted were collected May–June 2026 for a specific test profile and do not represent any individual’s actual rate. Car insurance rates vary by state, driver profile, vehicle, and insurer underwriting criteria. Get individual quotes to determine your actual rate. This article contains affiliate links.